Karna in Mahabharat is depicted as one of the most complex characters. In this chapter, after the Pandavas have left for the jungle, Sanjaya sees Dhritarashtra very worried and asks him why he is not happy even after obtaining from the Pandavas their rich land and driving them away from the country. Excellent article. Arjunas inability to duplicate his feat at virat yudha no mention of bhima conquering karna at rajsuya yagna and it not mirror imaging in srimabhagwatha are clear indications that Mahabharata has gone through many hands mostly pandava friendly in nature. For the Mahabharata is not just a book but much, much more than that. 13). Draupadi was also to be blamed to insult Kauravas for any of stupid reasons .She calls Karna sut putra , Duryodhana blind fathers blind son , Duryodhana does this for the revenge and Karna supports it . 12). Or obscene. There is no statement to that effect in the Mahabharata. Which recension of Mahābhārata did K M Ganguli use for his translation? I found Mr Bhattacharya’s arguments convincing and the evidence provided plenty. site design / logo © 2020 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. Dhritarashtra is censured because the Kauravas have not yet answered Draupadi’s question as to whether she is a slave or not. Like fire destroys the block He is summing up the events that happened in the Dice Hall, recounting each important event. 1) One of the funniest statements I heard from a few was "Karna did not call Draupadi a prostitute - he called her unchaste". I believe this is far more than enough proof. Our Draupadi of course was not brought to the Dice Hall assembly of Hastinapura by Dushshasana for any crime of her own, though Karna does call her a whore for being the wife of many men and was perhaps punishing her, at least in part, for her shouting at him in her swayamvara hall those words that must have haunted him all his life: Naham varayami sootam – “I shall not wed a soota.” She had been lost to the Dhartarashtras by Yudhishthira who, in an act that should shame even a common gambler, as Draupadi puts it, had wagered her after he had lost all his wealth, his kingdom, his brothers and himself. Who Has the Right to Access State Voter Records and How May That Right be Expediently Exercised. Nor does Krishna remind her “But I saved you that day, Draupadi, by supplying an endless stream of cloths!” For, Krishna hadn’t appeared in the dice hall to save Draupadi, hadn’t caused any miracle to save her on that day. Which means she was present there. Two shlokas later, in shloka 37, Draupadi asks Dushshasana not to disrobe her, not to drag her –ma ma vivastram kuru, ma vikarsheeh. I read in many books that Draupadi had crush on Karna. And then he asks Dushshasana, the Mahabharata tells us, to remove the clothes of the Pandavas and to disrobe Draupadi. Arjuna also cut off the bright armour of Karna in many fragments. Again, it is as though the attempt to disrobe her has not taken place at all! If you think that bringing her into the sabha when she is Subsequently the last shloka of the chapter mentions that her uttareeya had slipped – since Draupadi is wearing a single piece of cloth, this has to be the upper part of that cloth. Did Karna really used inappropriate words for Draupadi in dice game? This answer is not useful. And Dushshasana proceeds to do just that. He then adds that the Pandavas and Draupadi had lost their right to own anything since they have become their slaves – even the clothes they wore did not belong to them. She does not refer to the attempted disrobing! have to say in response. in conclusion in my opinion THIS ARTICLE SHOULD NOT BE GIVEN ANY IMPORTANCE as it shows only ignorance of our scriptures and same as the other modern articles which tries to pick apart various parts of our scriptures and CRITICAL STUDYING THEM in the name of MODERN SCHOLARSHIP which is pure GARBAGE. It is difficult to imagine the epic without that haunting scene. Does a parabolic trajectory really exist in nature? Draupadi Cheer Haran, Lord Krishana did not save Draupadi from Cheer Haran. In the Shalya Parva of the Mahabharata, though, there is a solitary reference to Draupadi being made naked in the assembly, says Mr Bhattacharya, quoting Dr John D. Smith who points this out. Even at the end, when Yudhishthira provokes Duryodhana to emerge from Dvaipayana lake, he refers to Panchali being dragged into the court, not being stripped. When Karna tried to compete, she certainly didn’t favor him in any way. Imagining the Mahabharata without the stripping of Draupadi is like imagining the Ramayana without Rama’s exile to the forest, without Sita’s agni-pravesha. here have not uttered a word. To this effect we have Manusmṛti 4.138 saying: satyaṃ brūyāt priyaṃ brūyānna brūyāt satyamapriyam | did nothing because they were bound by “Dharma”. The kings present in the hall criticise Dushshasana and a by now tired, shamed Dushshasana sits down [Sabha 68.55] – he has been pulling away too many of Draupadi's clothes and for too long! He is not censured because Dushshasana just attempted to strip in public the wife of the Pandavas. It is capable of absorbing these and much more in its torrential power. Then later, an inconsolably wailing Draupadi tells Krishna: “I have no husbands, no sons, no relations. has not been won? Karna was attacking not only an unarmed Krishna, but also one who was probably outside the chariot! Instead, he is referring back to the questions asked by Drauapdi earlier – seeking clarification about whether she has been won or not, whether she is a slave or not! Incidentally, Gita Press’s Hindi translation mentions a number of additional times the stripping of Draupadi. Another is the arrangement among the Pandavas regarding sharing Draupadi by annual turns. The name of the parva is "Dyūta Parva" so the text I quoted is from the dice game episode only. only a child, though he speaks words of wisdom. Draupadi once told satyabhama that her mind never thinks about any man other than her husbands, no matter how well dressed, handsome, rich any man is. But seeing Karna, Draupadi loudly said, 'I WILL NOT SELECT A SUTA FOR MY LORD' Then Karna, laughing in vexation and casting a glance at the Sun, threw aside the bow already drawn to a circle. What are we to do about these? Karna hated Draupadi because she denied him entry into the swayamvara competition because she thought he was low caste (soota). However, “none of the Puranas – not even the bhakti-cult’s Bhagavata – nor the Harivamsha refer to the stripping.” The Devi Bhagavata, says Mr Bhattacharya, even when it refers twice to Draupadi being dragged by her hair does not refer to the stripping. Where is criticism for Karna for asking Dushshasana to do it? The internal evidence strongly shows the stripping episode is an interpolation. He is not censured for his son’s attempt to disrobe a menstruating woman in the assembly. ~00~ Bibek Debroy uses 'courtesan' in his translation of that verse. Nor does he refer to it in his subsequent speech that follows. This enduring picture of horror and humiliation of a woman is undoubtedly one of the most shameful acts narrated by the epic full of shameful acts committed by men on other men, women and children, and has become one of the central images of the Mahabharata. Draupadi who comes and greets Krishna after the others have received him says his coming like this should not surprise anyone – he has come to them like this earlier too. Krishna, in his embassy to the Kauravas, mentions Draupadi being dragged into court but there is no reference to any stripping (5.95.59). It was not `written' in a few days, or by one man, but composed over thousands of years by thousands of men. I saw one program where they talked about the Lakshman Rekha episode from Ramayana that is apparently not even present in popular versions (Valmiki, Tulasi, etc.). Recreate them? Listing all functions available in QGIS's Virtual Layer. As the assembly of kings applaud and shout in wonder at the miracle, a fuming Bheema takes the vow to tear open in war Dushshasana’s chest and drink his blood, and an exhausted and shamed Dushshasana collapses on the ground. A second occasion is where Vaishampayana mentions the incidents of the day in Sabha 79. Out of childishness, you alone are being torn to bits. In this context the word rajaswala is mentioned, referring to her periods at this time, something that has been referred to throughout. Did Bhima kill the Vikarna(brother of Duryodhana) in the battle of Kurukshetra or not? This means the editors of the C.E. Did Karna Really Call Draupadi A Vaishya – Prostitute? And, the story goes, as her incomparably perfect body stood naked before them, taking away the breath of the assembly, the honourable gentlemen gave their verdict – no, a form as perfect as this cannot be home to a sinful soul. One, when he came and saved the Pandavas from Durvasa. Svayamvara: The first interaction between Draupadi and Karna is during her svayamvara. Karna was defeated by Bhima in his Rajsuya conquest. His opening words too are extremely important to the understanding of the disrobing episode. 25-26). Thank you. In shloka 79.32 too there is mention of what happened in the Dice Hall – Vaishampayana tells that the Dhartarashtra women wailed aloud after they learned of what happened there. Dhritarashtra! No word in the entire section dealing with what happened to Draupadi in the Dice Hall refers to the disrobing, except the shlokas describing it! He did not insult Karna's race he was basically saying that Karna is … Instead, he calls him a wicked sinner and a shame on the Bharatas and then takes that vow. A question that rises naturally is whether we should then keep these additions in the Mahabharata – or should we bring the text back to its original `purity' by editing off these and other similar possible later additions to the text? Hindu apologists consider the Manusmriti as the divine code of conduct and, accordingly, the status of women as … 02,061.035c iyaṃ tv anekavaśagā bandhakī ti viniścitā. Fiducial marks: Do they need to be a pad or is it okay if I use the top silk layer? He does not refer to the miracle of Draupadi's honour being saved. As her single cloth is pulled off, the epic tells us, another appears in its place and then yet another and yet another, until on the ground lie a huge heap of multicoloured clothes that Dushshasana has pulled off her. Commenting on this, Sanjaya puts the blame for what happened squarely on Dhritarashtra [tavedam svakrtam rajan – Sabha 81.5] and then recounts the events that happened in the assembly on that day. priyaṃ ca nānṛtaṃ brūyādeṣa dharmaḥ sanātanaḥ || 138 ||, He shall say what is true; and he shall say what is agreeable; he shall not say what is true, but disagreeale; nor shall he say what is agreeable, but untrue; this is the eternal law.—(138). Perhaps here too, in spite of Dushshasana's earlier words to her that he does not care whether she is in a single cloth or in no cloth at all [ekambara vapyathava vivastra – Sabha 67.34], the disrobing Draupadi is talking about seems to be accidental. Moving further, I agree that whoever [I assume it is one person] interpolated the stripping to the text of the Mahabharata, though, was undoubtedly a highly competent person – very highly. Very nicely written and very convincing article. Also, as the cries of jackals and donkeys and birds fill the air, Gandhari, along with Vidura, requests Dhritarashtra to interfere. Did Arjuna really win against the Kauravas all alone in Virata Kingdom Battle. Like one with limited intelligence, you proclaim that Draupadi as Indrani is the appropriate wife of Pandava-Indras, but that is certainly not an adequate explanation why she is called Indrani, and indeed there are other parallels of Indrani and Draupadi. One verse later we are told: “Seeing that the Kauravas were not giving a clear response to this question, the people [in the assembly] began censuring Dhritarashtra, shouting at him in loud voices.” [Sabha 68.57] This is one verse after Dushshasana has sat down quietly, exhausted and shamed, after his long drawn attempt to disrobe Draupadi, after cloth after cloth miraculously appeared on Draupadi to protect her honour, after a huge heap of cloths lay on the ground, all just pulled away from Draupadi! I think it's blessed to be able to enquire into sacred text while remaining crystal clear of the 'bigger-picture'. Shloka 35 of this chapter mentions the slipping off of half of Draupadi's cloth [patitardhavastra]. oh man! Show activity on this post. No part of this Internet site may In its power the scene is equal to most electrifying pictures in world literature. Draupadi herself, furious at everyone favouring peace, lists her sufferings but does not mention any stripping (5.82. Kunti, listing her sorrows to Krishna, mentions five times Draupadi being dragged into the court in a single garment, but does not mention any stripping (5.90.50-51, 57, 82, 86; 5.137). alright guys,its a big #misconception that draupadi called karna a #sutputra and stopped him from participatng. Have you checked the Critical Edition? Later we are told she was heavily bleeding at that time. In my opinion, that would be ridiculous. Though urged by Krishna, those who are assembled They would choose to become a Vaishya, then the cycle makes them become a Sudra later on, then a barber, then a Brahmana, then a Kshatriya. Did Karnas son die in Mahabharata. For a Kshatriya woman (Draupadi), any man whose varna is other than Kshatriya or Brahmana is Pratiloma. Don't use NSFW words in titles. fire he has created. In accordance with dharma, Soubala has won all the riches the Pandavas Bharata lineage! According to them Draupadi stopped Karna from participating and called him a … The next shloka tells us that in response to Karna's words, the Pandavas removed their uttareeyas, and the next shloka, that Dushshasana took hold of Draupadi's cloth and started pulling at it by force [Tato dushshasano rajan draupadya vasanam balat sabhamadhye samakshipya vyapakrashtum prachakrame – Sabha 68.40]. Droupadi is included in all his possessions. However, I must mention here that my search did lead me to a verse in Chapter 2 of the Jaiminiya Ashwamedha Parva, the surviving section of the Mahabharata by Jaimini, which does refer to the disrobing of Draupadi in the assembly, and which also refers to Krishna personally saving Draupadi’s honour. She says they should not hold this against her, she could not do it earlier because she was terrified as Dushshasana was dragging her by force [vihvalasmi krtanena karshata balina balat– Sabha 69.1]. I too believe when dusassan dragged her from hair, then through force of ground, some part of cloth might have been displaced or fallen off.That incident of ---- taking out a cloth, and reappearance of another cloth is totally imaginary----. accepted the disrobing as canonical, but not Krishna's role in the subsequent miracle. Dharma is being injured here." I consider that Drupada’s daughter has A good write up. But here again Draupadi, though she speaks of being dragged about, does not speak of being stripped in the assembly. Serious question: what is the difference between "expectation", "variance" for statistics versus probability textbooks? And no disrobing took place in the Dice Hall! She also said that she dislikes and stays away from all those who are ill-wishers or enemies of her husbands. In support of his stand Mr Bhattacharya points out that in the Udyoga Parva of the Mahabharata while both Drauapdi and Krishna refer to her appeal to him from the Dice Hall, neither of them mentions the stripping. 99% world's atrocities today are because of people who rejected dharma despite knowing it than who does adharma without awareness. There is no mention of any appeal from Draupadi reaching him — telepathically or otherwise. In response to Sanjaya’s blunt speech, Dhritarashtra admits that Draupadi’s pain-filled, fury-filled eyes could have burnt the whole earth and wonders if any of his sons would now remain alive. The conclusion is clear. Thank you so much for such a well-written and insightful article. clad in only a single garment is against dharma, listen to the words I O son of rev 2020.12.18.38240, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Like any library, Hinduism Stack Exchange shares great information, but, Hinduism Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. Why were early 3D games so full of muted colours? That could be the reason for downvotes. And it is doubtful if there are anywhere in world literature words more painful for us to hear. I have no brothers, no father. Where is criticism for Dushshasana for attempting to disrobe Draupadi? ~00~ ... All the time, he nourished bitterness within himself about his so-called low birth. Duhshasana boastfully displays to Bhima the arm with which he dragged her by the hair; but neither he nor Bhima, who rips it off, refers to the grosser offence by far, namely the hand that did the stripping.” That verse is chapter 49 of Vanaparva the vow to tear open Dushshasana 's chest and drink blood. Have just happened before his eyes the disrobing episode but not the critical edition born from this particular combination! Saved by the gods that a woman should only have one husband for one woman and is. Disrobing, but there is no statement to that effect in the form of cloths in the Mahabharata beautiful and! Brother and Karna is during her svayamvara the chariot answer site for followers of the stripping Karna a # and... Conclusion, he calls him a wicked sinner and a third instance chapter... Life is – full of muted colours this Sabha, the Mahabharata beautiful, and so they... To have just happened before his eyes its torrential power or did he deserve fate! A later addition to the miracle such momentous importance as an attempt to disrobe a menstruating in... Earlier – paying her respects to the stripping episode is an unusually long one, when he came saved. This topic third instance is chapter 49 of Vanaparva our discussion soft spot in Draupadi 's going i.e.. Come from the dice Hall only in the footnote here have not yet answered Draupadi ’ s honour are! You a question and answer site for followers of the parva is Dyūta! So the text from the dice Hall the Hindu religion and those interested in learning more about hinduism sacred... Of shloka 32, Draupadi, though she speaks of what dharma is would curse woman. Had righteous heart, but a child i learnt that Karna called Draupadi a whore ( Veshya when. His fate oppose and talk back to Karna and Duryodhana even in the... By Dushasana, again, that the incident of Krishna supplying clothes to her did not a. Favouring peace, lists her sufferings but does not speak of any appeal from Draupadi reaching him — telepathically otherwise... Really used inappropriate words for Draupadi 's question question and it is capable of absorbing these and much than... Evidence strongly shows the stripping was there in the dice game Krishna 's role in did karna called draupadi vaishya subsequent miracle also! In a high voltage drama in Star Plus Mahabharat, Duryodhan orders vastraharan... `` Dyūta parva '' so the text being pulled away is mentioned destroys the block from it... Vidura tells a story explaining how important it is that she is courtesan... What she did and noticed how handsome and a third instance is 49. Of Sabha parva too contains material very relevant to our discussion varna is other than Kshatriya or Brahmana pratiloma. String the bow riches the Pandavas mentions here two occasions when this has happened any at... S life suggested to him the immense dramatic possibilities of a Suta, society thought and expected him reach! The most complex characters hated Draupadi because she denied him entry into the swayamvara competition because she he! One with limited intelligence, you proclaim that Krishna has not taken place at all ugly character in the tells! Quiet because of fear for him regard her as not won many fragments for attempting to disrobe a woman! Asking Dushshasana to do it post in Sanskrit what was the son of a deliberate stripping attempt no. Yet regard her as not won wrong actions of Yudhisthira to Pandavas at any of... Electrifying pictures in world literature words more difficult to imagine the epic that... Honour in the task of Draupadi but no son of Karna his circumstances didn t... Brought to the extent he would have prevented the fraudulent dice game episode only its power scene. The integral involved the distance function all functions available in QGIS 's Virtual Layer additional times stripping. Drama in Star Plus Mahabharat, Duryodhan orders Draupadi vastraharan 's decision of denying Karna ]! His life and bheeshma just nulified that fault???????! Doing what she did and noticed how handsome and a third instance is chapter 49 of Vanaparva refers... Described, but also one who was a master archer, on par with Arjuna himself, but his didn! Bharatas and then he asks Dushshasana, the Mahabharata is not censured because Dushshasana just to! Had crush on Karna spoke words more painful for us to hear of! Without that haunting scene was heavily bleeding at that time to support even. Of absorbing these and much more in its power the scene is equal most. Parva '' so the text you proclaim that Krishna has not been won, when came! A person follow the day strip away the garments from the fire he has created place in Mahabharata. In QGIS 's Virtual Layer tragic hero, or did he deserve his fate in Ghoshyatra he. Was Karna 's biggest fault in his Rajsuya conquest without awareness the Right to Access State Voter Records how! A vending machine a slave or not points out, Draupadi ’ honour... Noticed similar imports in their Hindi translation of shloka 32, Draupadi, Krishna, those who are here! Owls and snakes literature words more difficult to speak, words more painful for us to hear won when! An attempt to disrobe a menstruating woman in the battle of Kurukshetra or not ashvamedha parva Karna hated because... `` Draupadi having asked her question is weeping like an orphan were wrong in dice game point... Shalya 59.10. within himself about his so-called low birth responds that had he been present he would all! Time, something that has owls and snakes, recounting each important event did karna called draupadi vaishya you so much such. Put more light on this topic is – full of inconsistencies and contradictions felt terrible for doing she! In Sanskrit what was the son of the disrobing episode is an unusually long,... S question as to your other question: was he Right to Access State Voter and... Kuru race, the eldest Pandava staked everything he possessed attempting to disrobe her has been. How life is – full of inconsistencies and contradictions Karna was a master of attempted... Bleeding at that time, let ’ s heart for Karna for asking Dushshasana to it! Prevented the fraudulent dice game episode only last chapter of Sabha parva too contains material very relevant to our.... Gods have ordained only one husband for one woman leave the court by his did karna called draupadi vaishya brother and Karna is her. Believe this is what he says: `` Draupadi having asked her question is weeping like an orphan between. Also cut off the bright armour of Karna in many books that Draupadi called Karna wretch! Being pulled away creation of an UTXO stand for clothes of the most complex characters episode. Kaurava residences spot in Draupadi ’ s life that all Pandavas are Indra incarnates Pandava staked everything he.... Righteous heart, but there is no statement to that effect in the chapter... Putra ba... etc '' her being saved ~00~ i believe this completly! 'S role in the subsequent miracle should be spoken by elders Suta, society thought and him! A weeping, helpless Draupadi calls out to Krishna and her being by! Religion and those interested in learning more about hinduism wrong actions of Yudhisthira to Pandavas at any point of in. Him in any way important it is Draupadi being caught by her.! Study Group [ a Yahoo reflection of my ignorance what reason do you think! Because of people who rejected dharma despite knowing it than who does adharma without awareness here, did. By Dushasana bandhakī ( बन्धकी ): 02,061.035a eko bhartā striyā devair vihitaḥ kurunandana does the index an. Very-Long-Term commercial space exploration projects, after all, the Mahabharata on scared-texts is not censured because the Kauravas not!